People with this are normal. It’s the people without it that are mutants. What is it?

clipart.com

Answer: Lactose intolerance

Clues: “Sensitivity” and “Dairy”

People with lactose intolerance are normal, people without lactose intolerance are mutants.  Humans all used to be lactose intolerant, people who aren’t have a mutated gene that allows them to process dairy.

Lactose intolerance – Wikipedia